Skip to Main Content

Peer Review

In simple terms, peer review is a quality control process applied to an author's scholarly work and is designed to ensure that published works are valid, original and of high quality.


Related terms you should be aware of...

The terms "peer reviewed" and "refereed" mean the same thing. That is, the work has been subjected to a quality control review by experts in the relevant field of research.

When an authors research has undergone the peer review process and been published in a journal, the published article can be called a "peer-reviewed article". When a journal publisher applies the peer review process to all articles they publish, then the journal can be referred to as a "peer reviewed journal".

At university you sometimes hear about "scholarly" or "academic" works and these terms may be used to mean "peer reviewed". It is recommended that you seek clarification as not all scholarly or academic works have undergone a formal peer review process.


The value of Peer Review

There can be debate in academic circles about whether peer review is useful and whether it adds any value to the academic and research process. Here are some opinions that students should be aware of.

Benefits

  • Reviews conducted by relevant experts and respected researchers improves the quality of published papers.
  • The review process motivates authors to submit good quality work.
  • By testing for originality, the process encourages the distribution of new findings and discoveries.

Criticism

  • The process does not fully eliminate reviewer’s human error, bias, or conflict of interest.
  • It can take a long time to complete the process, thus delaying the publication of current research and new ideas.
  • Different publishers apply varying levels of rigour to their peer review process.

 

Subjects: All guides, Study and research guides